December is a time of joy, kindness, and community. In the nonprofit world, it is often referred to as “The Giving Season,” as this single month accounts for up to 30% of annual fundraising.
With hundreds of worthy nonprofit organizations here on the Mid-Shore, mailboxes are already overflowing with year-end donation requests. It’s important to develop a year-end fundraising strategy that can help cut through the noise and reach the people who have a heart for your organization’s mission. Your appeal letter, emails, social media posts, and other media coverage form the basis of a successful plan, but don’t overlook an asset that can super-charge your fundraising efforts – your Board of Directors!
In my October article, I discussed best practices for engaging your board in fundraising, including a list of ideas for year-end board participation. Since we’re now in the thick of it, I thought this would be a perfect opportunity to provide a refresher on some of those ideas, along with more context about the importance of board fundraising.
As I spoke about in my last article, fundraising is less about the ask and more about building a connection between a donor and your mission. We call this relational versus transactional fundraising. If a donor is emotionally invested in your mission, he or she is more likely, not just to give, but to give at a higher level and over a longer period of time.
Along with key staff, your Board of Directors should be the top ambassadors - and therefore, the top relationship-builders – for your organization. There are countless ways your board can participate in relational fundraising during the month of December.
If your appeal letters aren’t in the mail yet, line up board members to write notes at the top of or attached to your letter, thanking donors for their support and encouraging them to give this year-end. Bonus points if you can match board member notes with people they already have relationships with! Instead of getting a simple form letter, donors will receive a more personal and heartfelt message.
Ask some of your board members to give testimonials about why they give to your organization. Depending on how you want to use these, they can be written, voice recordings, or videos. In marketing, there is a concept called “social proof” which essentially means that if people see someone like themselves doing something, they are more likely to do that thing. By sharing their stories of support, board members can influence others to take action.
A matching challenge is a great way to motivate donors during a campaign. If you have a board member who is planning to make a large year-end gift, ask if he or she would be willing to leverage it and challenge the community (or family and friends) to match the donation amount. A group of board members can also pool their donations to offer an even bigger match amount.
You may have board members who are comfortable asking family and friends to donate to your organization instead of giving holiday gifts. Similarly, encourage board members who are hosting holiday events to include a “mission moment” during the event, where the board member or a key staff member can address the guests, talk a bit about the mission, and ask for their support.
Those who are involved in local businesses can post campaign materials in their workplace, or even host a promotion for your organization, where a percentage of proceeds from a particular day or from the sale of a particular product are donated in support of your mission.
Getting the donation is not the end of the donor journey. Recruit board members for handwritten thank you notes, phone calls, or even videos. Acknowledgement/tax letters are mandatory, but highly impersonal. For a better chance of retaining your donors, make sure to thank them fervently and inform them of the impact of their gift. A personal thank you is memorable and shows your donors that they are valued. Ask your board members to put some thought and effort into these. I have personally stopped giving to more than one organization where it was obvious the show of thanks was compulsory and not a display of genuine gratitude.
The above examples are not an exhaustive list, but rather a great jumping off point. Engaging your board in any number of these or similar activities can take your year-end fundraising to the next level and help your organization make the most of “The Giving Season.”
I wish you all tons of success and a very happy holiday season. Thank you for everything you have done this year to uplift our community and make it such a special place to live! I look forward to a prosperous 2027 for all!