What's Good

Involving Your Nonprofit Board In Fundraising – Don’t Let It Spook You

Posted

It might be the “spooky season,” but you should never be afraid to approach your Board of Directors about participating in fundraising efforts for your nonprofit.
One item discussed in last month’s strategic planning article was that your staff does not make up your organization’s full capacity. Your Board of Directors is comprised of people with varying talents and areas of expertise who can help you implement plans and achieve success.
Nonprofit Boards have two key functions: Governance and Fundraising. My paperwork crusade falls under Governance - the duty to oversee the effective implementation of your nonprofit’s mission and to provide proper financial stewardship. Most Board Members happily hop on the Governance train. However, in order to be good financial stewards, there must be funding to manage. Your Board also has duty to ensure your organization has the resources necessary to carry out its mission. This part of the job is usually met with much less enthusiasm.
Why is the fundraising conversation so difficult? In my experience, there are three main reasons why this topic falls flat.
1.Your approach may be off-putting.
Fundraising asks are typically transactional. For instance, “everyone must sell 50 tickets to our spring gala,” or “give or get $10,000.” Many people will shut down immediately with this approach. Asking people for money is incredibly uncomfortable for all but a rare few.
The best fundraising strategy is relational – focused on building relationships between donors and the mission rather than simply asking for money. Donors with an emotional investment in your mission are likely to make a financial investment. They are also more likely to give more and give for longer.
The relational approach also transforms the conversation with your Board. Board Members don’t necessarily need to be the askers, so their tasks might look more like, “bring a friend to our spring gala,” “invite someone who has shown interest in our mission for a tour of our facilities” or “give a happy dollar and share a mission moment at Rotary each week.” This may be far more palatable and also brings me to point number 2.
2.You might be treating all of your Board Members the same.
Your Board Members are unique human beings with their own availability, energy levels, comfort levels, talents, and interests. The relational approach to fundraising opens a world of opportunities to participate in development efforts. If Board Members can commit to tasks that work specifically for them, they will be much more likely to fulfill those commitments. Don’t forget: this may require some assistance – and persistence – on your part.
3.You are likely not being upfront about expectations.
Because fundraising has historically been an unpleasant conversation, it is often glossed over with prospective Board Members. You must be transparent about all aspects of Board participation and explain exactly what is expected of those with a leadership role in your organization.
There is a fear that discussing fundraising will cause some prospects to not join your Board. It very well might, but that’s not a bad thing. Which is more helpful to your organization: someone who is listed as a Board Member on your website, but does not fulfill his/her leadership duties, or someone who understands the Board’s role and is willing to put in the time and effort to help your nonprofit achieve its goals?
If fundraising causes some people to say no to Board Membership, remember, they aren’t saying no to the organization itself. It just means the Board is not the right role for them. Finding a better fit will help build a stronger relationship. Having this discussion up front saves a lot of time, energy, and frustration in the future.
Implementing relational fundraising for year-end efforts
Year-end fundraising is a perfect opportunity to harness your Board’s energy for campaign success. There is a lot Board Members can do to help boost your year-end numbers, including:
•Writing personal notes on the appeal letters for people they know.
•Sending handwritten thank you notes or making personal thank you calls.
•Leveraging a large donation into a match challenge, either for friends and family or for the community.
•Inviting your Executive Director to attend his/her holiday party and talk about your organization.
•Encouraging friends and family to donate in lieu of gifts.
•Displaying promotional materials or a donation box/QR Code in his/her place of business.
•Sharing social medial posts related to your organization and the appeal.
•Giving a testimonial about why they choose to support your organization.
The options are endlessly customizable. Start by engaging your Board Members for your year-end efforts and then work them in to the development plan for the full fiscal year. Everyone working as a team can level up your organizational capacity and bring your fundraising goals to fruition!